Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars
PRESS CONFERENCE
Rahm Emanuel (ANS) & new chief of staff Pete Rouse (BOM) are antithetical
— I always love Andy’s portrayal of Rahm Emanuel. A bit of a shame this is one of the last times we’re going to see it (he makes one more appearance in the cold opening of this season’s Jeff Bridges episode).
— Good turn with Andy’s Emanuel giving Bobby’s Pete Rouse frightening, overly-intense advice.
— Bobby’s nervousness and whininess as Rouse is pretty funny.
STARS: ***½
MONOLOGUE
host hopes to up his name recognition with “Charlie Kane” variant
— Funny underwear photos of Bryan Cranston throughout his career.
— Geez, they’re wasting Bryan on a freakin’ song-and-dance monologue? And a very generic one at that? (*sigh*)
— Nothing particularly noteworthy about the song, except a laugh from the big photo of “Bryan Cranston” (really Bill Paxton) that Nasim is briefly seen carrying into the shot.
STARS: **
PEPTO-BISMOL ICE
Pepto-Bismol Ice brings diarrhea relief during a night of clubbing
— A decent and strangely-kinda-cool premise of a version of Pepto-Bismol that’s marketed as a malt liquor for clubbing.
— Pretty funny interaction between Andy and Nasim.
STARS: ***
THE MILEY CYRUS SHOW
Miley Cyrus (VAB) doesn’t let Johnny Depp (PAB) say much
— Wow, it shows a lot of confidence on SNL’s part to place such a big Vanessa Bayer showcase in the lead-off spot of this episode, when Vanessa’s only in her second episode as a featured player.
— Vanessa’s take on Miley Cyrus is very solid. This is an important moment for her, as it ends up being her breakout role.
— Odd to see in retrospect that the first installment of this soon-to-be-recurring-sketch has Bryan playing Billy Ray Cyrus, given the fact that Jason would take over the role in all subsequent installments.
— I love that tonight’s lead-off sketch is now heavily featuring TWO newbies, as Paul (in his first noteworthy SNL role) has now shown up as Vanessa-as-Miley’s interviewee, Johnny Depp.
— Turns out Paul’s performance as Depp is nothing to write home about. He’s doing a pretty generic take on Depp, and it’s not showing off Paul’s comedic skills.
— Given how new Vanessa is, it’s charming seeing her soaking in the extended audience laughter she gets after she says “Yeah, me, too” in response to Paul’s Depp saying he’s taken on darker roles.
STARS: ***½
WHAT UP WITH THAT? BACK TO SCHOOL EDITION
Morgan Freeman & Ernest Borgnine [real] sit & watch
— Vanessa has taken over Jenny Slate’s role as one of the backup singers of this recurring sketch, and Taran has taken over Will Forte’s role as the announcer.
— Great guests in tonight’s What Up With That: Morgan Freeman and Ernest Borgnine!
— I love the anxious, stifled-mouth look on Kenan’s face during Morgan Freeman’s serious spiel about school (the sixth above screencap for this sketch).
— Absolutely hilarious visual of Bryan as a George Clinton-esque singer. Also, the detail of him in briefs is a good callback to the monologue.
— The “back to school” theme of tonight’s What Up With That is adding a nice bit of a change of pace to this recurring sketch’s formula.
— I like the creepy-eyed look on Paul’s face during the Mary Kay Letourneau / Vili Fualaau bit.
— The big open-mouthed smile on Ernest Borgnine’s face throughout this sketch is so fun and charming.
STARS: ****½
BASKETBALL GAME
on a basketball court, Shana simultaneously attracts & repels co-workers
— For the second time tonight, Taran has taken over a recurring Will Forte role.
— On a similar note, Abby has taken over the “ignored girl” role that Casey Wilson and Jenny Slate played in the previous two installments of this recurring sketch. Unlike Casey and Jenny, Abby doesn’t end up suffering the “curse”, in which each cast member who plays the “ignored girl” role in this recurring Shana sketch gets fired before getting to appear in a second Shana sketch.
— Bryan’s disturbing turned-on facial reactions to Shana’s actions are pretty funny. He’s making something out of a fairly nothing role.
— As usual, standard Shana stuff, but it still works for me. What doesn’t work for me in these sketches, however, is the repetitiveness of Andy, Kenan, and Will/Taran’s reactions to Shana.
— Hmm, this installment is going a little too heavy on the burp/fart humor.
— This sketch surprisingly ends up being Kristen’s ONLY appearance all night, believe it or not.
STARS: **½
RESCUE DOGS 911 APP
emergency response promotes movie & thwarts robbery; Helen Mirren cameo
— An extremely random brief cameo from Helen Mirren (who will be hosting later this season) in the Rescue Dogs promo shown on Andy’s phone.
— For the names shown in Andy’s address book, SNL uses the first and/or last names of SNL writers and other staffers from around this time, strangely even including two writers who got fired (or left on their own, I’m not sure) after the preceding season: Hannibal Burress and Jillian Bell.
— A laugh from Kenan’s “Let’s shoot this motherf(*bleep*)” and subsequent gunshot when Bobby has shown up as the pizza delivery guy.
— Good visual of the rescue dog chewing off Fred’s arm.
STARS: ***
MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Power”
WEEKEND UPDATE
Anthony Crispino is misinformed about Ground Zero mosque & LeBron James
as her comic strip run comes to an end, Cathy (ANS) plans for retirement
— Bobby’s second-hand news guy, Anthony Crispino, has officially become recurring.
— Like last time, some amusing false into relayed by Bobby’s Crispino, though his false info tonight feels a little less funny than the ones from his first appearance.
— Seth sure loves breaking out that German accent whenever he does an Update joke about Germany. I love his delivery during the World War I Reparations joke tonight.
— This is the first time Andy’s Cathy has appeared in over a year, and, I believe, the last time we’d end up seeing her.
— Hilarious how the sentimental Cathy goodbye montage consists of just two brief clips.
STARS: ***
KID SMARTZ
(KET) is lone contestant to rebuff emcee’s (host) kisses
— Bryan is a natural as a cheesy game show host.
— I see SNL’s doing a spoof of a real-life viral video of an early 1980s children’s game show host creepily taking delight in kissing his prepubescent female contestants on the cheek.
— Aaaaaaaand cue the obligatory “hilarious” man-on-man kissing between Bryan and Andy.
— This sketch now takes another horrible turn, with us not only getting a Kenan In A Dress sighting, but him portraying this particular female character in his tired “sassy black female” manner.
— Somehow, this sketch continues to get even worse as it goes along. What is the point of this mess?
— The Bryan/Andy portions of this sketch are some low-rent Vogelchecks-level shit.
— Overall, wow, that was just awful.
STARS: *
THE BJELLAND BROTHERS
zero-hit wonders (host) & (FRA) perform song about sparkling apple juice
— In both of Jason’s only appearances all night, including this sketch, he’s just playing a background role with no dialogue. Geez. Really, SNL? (Granted, one of those background roles of his was in What Up With That, where his background dancing always steals the show, but still, it’s fucking insane that a veteran as fantastic and reliable as Jason gets stuck in nothing but non-speaking background roles in an episode from his SEVENTH season.) Bill, who’s playing the guitarist in this sketch, has also gotten shockingly very little to do in tonight’s episode. All of this combined with Kristen only appearing in one sketch all night (albeit in a lead role) is quite jarring.
— This sketch is destroying my patience, between the annoyingly repetitive “I’ve sent a bottle of sparkling apple juice…etc.” singing, and the lame lines about how poorly the careers of Fred and Bryan’s characters have gone. Fred used to be so masterful at doing anti-comedy pieces back when he was in his prime earlier in his SNL tenure. This sketch’s seeming attempt at anti-comedy is just sad and frustrating.
— I could do without the audience participation bit.
— Lame ending line from Fred: “This is the only song we’re doing tonight.”
— Overall, the second consecutive sketch tonight that I absolutely hated. What’s happened to this episode all of a sudden?
— This sketch would later be replaced with the dress rehearsal version in reruns. Two big differences I remember in that version: 1) the placement of the cast members playing Fred and Bryan’s band is different, with Jason’s drummer character now being very visible behind Fred and Bryan during the entire sketch, instead of being off to the side where we can only occasionally see him whenever the camera cuts to a wide shot of the stage. 2) Whenever Fred and Bryan ask the audience to sing some of the lyrics of the repetitive chorus, the audience humorously doesn’t respond at all (keeping up this sketch’s illusion that nobody’s in attendance at Fred and Bryan’s concert), unlike the live version, where the audience did respond, which hurt the joke (as bad as the joke was).
STARS: *
MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest & Pusha T [real] perform “Runaway”
BASEMENT KARATE
fifth-grader Henry (NAP) suffers his dad’s (host) self-defense lessons
— A laugh from Bryan bluntly punching Nasim’s young boy character in the face when making him simulate an attack.
— Yet another solid characterization from Nasim as a child character. This character’s manner of describing the flaws in his own fighting performances throughout this sketch is amusing me.
STARS: ***½
i-SLEEP PRO
black noise generator allows (KET) to slumber peacefully
— A fairly cheap and stereotypical premise, but at the same time, it’s a pretty fun and unique way to utilize newbie Jay Pharoah’s talent for doing many voices, as he’s providing all of the various recorded “black noise” voices heard from the i-Sleep device.
— I particularly like the Friday bit, with Jay doing the voices of both Ice Cube and Chris Tucker’s characters from Friday. Odd, though, how Jay has done a Chris Tucker impression in the 10-to-1 segment in both of his first two episodes. This kinda reminds me of when Rachel Dratch, back when she was a new featured player, played Calista Flockhart/Ally McBeal in both of her first two episodes.
STARS: ***
GOODNIGHTS
IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS
— An okay episode, and, like a lot of other episodes from around this time, was not as bad as I had remembered. (As I mentioned in a recent review, I tore this episode apart in my original 2010 review of this episode, and, much like my original 2010 review of the Ryan Phillippe episode, it ended up receiving a lot of backlash from members of the now-defunct saturday-night-live.com message board, who felt I was being way too negative and “nerdy”.) That being said, that horrific one-two punch of Kid Smartz and The Bjelland Brothers airing back-to-back damn near destroyed me. Bryan Cranston sadly wasn’t used to his full potential in this episode, and was given a few too many poor roles, but he still managed to make the most of it.
MY PERSONAL CHOICE OF “BEST OF” MOMENTS FOR THIS EPISODE, REPRESENTED WITH SCREENCAPS
RATED SEGMENTS RANKED FROM BEST TO WORST
What Up With That? Back To School Edition
The Miley Cyrus Show
Basement Karate
Press Conference
Rescue Dogs 911 App
Weekend Update
Pepto-Bismol Ice
I-Sleep Pro
Basketball Game
Monologue
The Bjelland Brothers
Kid Smartz
HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING ONE (Amy Poehler)
a slight step down
My full set of screencaps for this episode is here
TOMORROW
Jane Lynch
Funny enough, “Sparkling Apple Juice” really seems to have stuck with people – I almost seem to remember that song being released on a 45 once?
Yes – I was correct; it was released as a 45 in 2014.
I consider this to be one of the all-time worse SNL episodes. Bryan was wasted and a lot of the sketches were forgettable to awful.
The studio audience was at an all-time worse. The yelling, hollering and cheering during the monologue was dreadful, especially with the underwear shots. It was even worse during the “Sparkling Apple Juice” sketch. The obnoxious audience signing along ruined the joke.
Kid Smartz was bad as I felt the kissing and Kenan’s character ruined it for me. People one the message boards were still complaining of not having a black female cast member, especially after Jay’s hiring.
Didn’t care for Shauna. It was same old hat. Lather. Rinse. Repeat.
As for The Miley Cyrus Show, it was a good debut. I think a lot of people forgot about Bryan after Jason took over the Billy Ray role. Had that sketch premiered now, they would keep having the host come back repeatedly.
Another okay show. “Kid Smartz” and Shana were the weak spots for me. Even though Bill, Suds, and Wiigy got the shaft tonight, all members of the “Class of 2010” (especially vBay) had highlights and prominent roles in this episode.
With a career that includes roles in From Here To Eternity, Marty, The Dirty Dozen and The Poseidon Adventure, I get the feeling that sitting in the What Up With That sketch is the most fun sex machine Ernest Borgnine ever spent on a set! Can you dig it?
The show Kid Smartz “parodies” is CTV’s original version of Just Like Mom during Fergie Olver’s hosting run. “Parodies” is in quotation marks as the original is self-parody to begin with, and bargain-bin Richard Dawson affectations to boot:
Holy creepy game show host! YIKES!!!!
I was somewhat disappointed with this episode. I guess I expected a lot from Bryan Cranston since I really admire his acting talent and I felt like he wasn’t quite used the way I wanted to see. Still some good sketches though. This particular What’s Up With That is one of my favorites, if only because I love the guests- Ernest Borgnine looked so happy to be there and it put a smile on my own face. The Digital Short is funny and Nasim’s performance in Basement Karate is just great.
This Shana sketch was the first one I saw, and I just didn’t get why the “ignored girl” role was needed. Felt like that added a weird unexplored dimension to the sketch, I kept expecting her to have more significance. It was less confusing after watching some of the other sketches.
This was also the first time I saw Andy Samberg as Cathy on Update, so I was so confused about the retrospective being so short, expecting that the character had appeared a lot more than they showed.
The sparkling apple juice song performance feels similar to the later Blue Jean Committee “Massachusetts Afternoon” performance sketch, except the latter to me was a charming and fun way to close the episode, while this one just falls flat.
Did not like the game show host sketch. I didn’t know it was a parody, but knowing that doesn’t make it much better.
I wish Bryan’s career had somehow allowed him to host in the mid 1980s–I think he would have done very well with that cast (I mean, I guess most people would).
Perhaps because I was living in Minneapolis at the time of this episode, but I have a soft spot, a guilty pleasure soft spot, for the “sparkling apple juice” sketch. It is a type of anti-comedy that I enjoy–extreme, asinine repetition–and I was a person who basically hated everything Fred was doing at this time. Perhaps because it is treated extremely straight. There isn’t like a reaction person or a straight man who keeps noting THIS IS THE SAME SONG OVER AND OVER. It walks a weird balance between being an anti-comedy sketch and a sketch with an audience–I could see a variant in which they lean into the studio audience accepting the joke and the sing-along is triumphant.
I mainly remember the first Miley Cyrus show and Ernest Borgnine and Morgan Freeman’s appearance in What Up with That. How great to see such a veteran as Borgnine having the time of his life on his only SNL appearance!
Hello Stooge. They Used To Have Richard Dawson Was The Host OF Family Feud ! Richard Dawson Would Kiss The Little Old Ladies On The Cheek ! Apparently, That Is What They Were Trying To Do And They Thought IT Would Have Been Funny IF Richard Dawson Had Kissed Another Man Even On The Mouth ! How Ever, Family Feud Was A Family Show !
Hey Stooge. That Audience From Fred And Bryan Brother Sketch Reminds Me OF The Audience In That First Show From The 46Th Season With Chris Rock ! There Were Some People Down In The Front, But, There Were People In The Balcony Just Like This Episode And They Did NOT Even Have A Corona Virus Situation ! Also, I Agree With You That They Could Have Had Jason In More Sketches With Dialogue Even With Bryan Cranston As The Host OF This Episode !
I had been watching the late ’00s consecutively up to this point. Something about this episode annoyed me on such a deep level that I never really got back into watching from one to another. I’m not even entirely sure why, but the main reason is I was disappointed at the colossal WASTE of Bryan Cranston. I am not saying he would have been a fantastic host, but I feel like we never even got the chance to know. Nothing was written for him, so much so that I end up wondering if they may have originally wanted to have a co-hosting gig with various Red cast members (who have more entertaining parts than he does).
The oddest part is I am not even a big Bryan Cranston fan – I don’t have a ton of interest in Malcolm in the Middle or Breaking Bad, and my main memories of him are from his days as a fun supporting character on King of Queens – but he was clearly an anticipated and talented host, so…do SOMETHING with the man. Unless it is one of those weeks where Lorne or NBC insist on stunt casting for ratings, I am never a fan of the idea of a host-proof SNL, which is what we essentially got here. (ironically, hosts in that arena, like Nancy Kerrigan, actually did get more focus than Bryan).
(the best I can say is that they at least avoided Breaking Bad homages, considering how clunky their attempt with him in 2016 is)
Other than being way too long, as per usual, I didn’t mind the sparkling apple juice sketch too much (it helped that I found the song to be catchy), but I HATE the Kid Smartz sketch. The sassy black girl trope (played by Kenan, naturally) was unbelievably stale and gross in 1940, let alone 2010. I don’t even understand how this trash got on the air.
Sorry – I meant watching in time with your recaps.
The original review Stooge did for this episode has always stuck with me as one of his best and most critical. I particularly remember him pointing out how Jason and Bill were treated as background extras, which is unusual for this point in their tenures. It seems every so often Jason would have a rough patch in terms of airtime, and in this season and episode in particular that is often the case. There’s like four or five episodes this season where he makes maybe two appearances and only one is a lead. Odd to consider, since Jason is seen as one of the alphas of this period and is very much (and deservedly) beloved by many. I basically remember his last three seasons were a guessing game as to whether or not he was leaving the show.
One thing that stands out most when comparing Stooge’s reviews here to his original takes on the old forum is how much he’s come around to What Up With That?, which he would regularly eviscerate as being indicative of the ‘cut copy paste’ nature of this era’s recurring characters. I like this installment best, mostly because of how much Borgnine is enjoying himself. He would have been a good Betty White-esque legacy host, even in his older years he had some sharp timing and was really funny in interviews
I like Bryan Cranston