April 11, 1981 – (no host) / Jr. Walker & The All Stars (S6 E13)

Segments are rated on a scale of 1-5 stars


COLD OPENING
amongst old SNL props, CHC & Mr. Bill reminisce about the good old days

   

— A hearty amount of immediate audience applause for Chevy’s backstage walk-on.
— Love seeing some of the costumes and props from the original SNL era, such as Bees costumes, the Coneheads prosthetics, and the (now cobweb-covered) Landshark head.
— The audience recognized Mr. Bill’s off-camera muffled yelling long before I did.
— Weird seeing a live Mr. Bill sketch.
— Nice subtle touch with having the prop sword Chevy uses on Mr. Bill be the familiar sword from the Samurai sketches.
— Overall, an enjoyable nostalgia trip, and a decent way to start the retooled version of SNL.
STARS: ***


OPENING MONTAGE

       

— I’ve always been curious to see this episode’s opening montage, because it ended up only being used this once, never appearing in any other episodes.
— Hey, they’re using the original SNL theme music from the first four seasons! Feels strange hearing that theme again.
— Maybe it’s just me, but I’m hearing some of season 5’s theme music in there as well. This sounds like a hybrid of both the original theme and the season 5 theme.
— Boy, are these credits low budget-looking as hell. Very short, too. Then again, I suppose it was known that this montage would only be used temporarily, so they probably figured “Why spend so much money on a new set of opening credits that might not last beyond this week?” Either that, or maybe they just simply didn’t have enough time to film a more elaborate set of credits. After all, Dick Ebersol was only given five weeks to retool the show, hire some new cast members, hire some new writers, etc.
— The new cast members making their debut tonight are repertory players Robin Duke, Tim Kazurinsky, and Tony Rosato, and featured players Laurie Metcalf and Emily Prager.


DRIVE FOR AMERICA
jingoistic Frank Sinatra (JOP) bashes Japan & promotes American cars

     

— In place of the monologue, we seem to be getting some kind of musical bit with Joe’s Frank Sinatra impression.
— Tony Rosato gets the honors of being the first of tonight’s newbies to make their first appearance.
— Joe as Sinatra: “We’re talkin’ Japs, ladies and gentlemen”. Oh, and I assumed season 6’s reliance on bad racial humor was something that went out the door with Doumanian. Then again, this IS Sinatra we’re talking about. He WOULD make a remark like that.
— So Yvonne Hudson is still hanging around, even despite no longer being credited as a featured player?
— Overall, not much to say about this and this wasn’t exactly the most exciting sketch premise to lead off “the new SNL” with. The sketch itself wasn’t too bad, though, and Tim Kazurinsky walked away with the best moments of the sketch.
STARS: **½


LITE BEER
in a bar, Bill Cosby (EDM) tries to sell a group of kids on Lite Beer

 

— The first real debut of Eddie’s Bill Cosby impression.
— It won’t be easy, but I’ll do my best to refrain from relating this sketch to the modern-day viewpoint of Cosby.
— The concept of a lite beer for children is fairly funny.
— I feel bad for Denny being a glorified extra in this, playing a silent waitress. Maybe I just feel bad about that because I know what lies ahead for her SNL future.
— The writing itself was pretty flimsy and felt like they ran out of funny lines for Eddie halfway through, but Eddie did his usual good job wringing laughs out of the whole thing.
STARS: ***


I MARRIED A MONKEY
(TIK) accuses his wife Madge of having an affair

   

— Starting a sketch with two of the new cast members. I’m already excited for this sketch.
— The name Madge? The use of soap opera music stings? Oh, I know where this is going…
— Yep, there’s the monkey. It’s the debut of “I Married a Monkey”!
— I like how the monkey is just casually stuffing its face full of bananas as Tim is delivering a dramatic rant to it.
— Hilarious part with the monkey actually drinking from the sugar bowl.
— Is Tim laughing right now, or just crying in character? Hard to tell.
— LOL, the blooper with the baby monkey refusing to let go of its off-camera handler while screeching like mad is a riot! Tim’s reactions to this unplanned madness are also great.
— That reminds me, I remember reading that Tim came up with the idea to do a sketch with live monkeys because he wanted to disprove a friend of his who didn’t believe that SNL is really a live show.
— Overall, I surprisingly enjoyed this quite a lot. I’m not sure I’m going to be crazy about them eventually making this into a recurring sketch, but I sure enjoyed this first installment, for Tim’s commitment, for all the unplanned antics from the monkeys, and for the daring idea of doing this sketch in the first place. It’s making me look forward to Tim’s tenure on the show.
STARS: ****


DISCLAIMER
stay tuned after SNL for Johnny Cash At Spandau Prison

— Odd placement for a disclaimer gag, showing it in the middle of an episode after a commercial break, instead of placing it at the very beginning of the show like they used to do in the original era.


MUSICAL GUEST INTRO
ROD introduces musical guest & credits him with inspiring SNL theme music

— Robin Duke makes her very first appearance.
— Robin acknowledges she hasn’t done much tonight but explains “You’ll be seeing more of me next week.” Kinda sad hearing that in hindsight, because thanks to a writers strike, we would end up having to wait until the fall to see more of her.
— Man, she’s coming off really stumbly with her lines all throughout this. First night jitters, I take it?
— Interesting tidbit about the original SNL theme music being influenced by tonight’s musical guest. That makes me look at that theme music differently now.
— I think I remember hearing that this ends up being the only thing Robin appears in all night.
STARS: N/A (not a rateable segment)


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “Roadrunner”
musical guest performs “Shotgun”


WEEKEND UPDATE, PART 1
Smitt-Burney makes money the old-fashioned way, they steal it
Raheem Abdul Muhammed saw Altered States but thought it was Stir Crazy
LAM asks pedestrians “Would you take a bullet for our president?”

         

— What’s with the weird intro voice-over doing the opening Smitt-Burney “We steal it” sponsorship promo?
— Hey, it’s Chevy at the original Update set! And doing his trademark “raunchy phone conversation” opening gag! Seeing all of this is flashing me back to when I was doing reviews of season 1 several months ago.
— Chevy’s opening “I’m Chevy Chase… and you still aren’t” line didn’t get anywhere near as big an audience reaction as you’d expect.
— Holy shit, a joke in 1981 about Mackenzie and John Phillips setting their wedding plans. WTF? Were these writers psychic?
— What’s with Chevy’s timing so far in tonight’s Update? He seems fairly awkward and “off”. Not quite as “off” as he was throughout his infamous season 5 hosting stint that I recently reviewed, but still a far cry from how good he was during his cast member days.
— It’s also not helping that the jokes themselves aren’t very good. However, it’s still a little better than the mind-numbingly unfunny dreck we were hearing from Rocket and Matthius all season.
— Ha, I like how when Chevy had trouble saying “This just in”, he ad-libbed some fast-paced Spanish gibberish, which is an old improv bit he used to fall back on during his days as a cast member whenever he would trip over an Update joke. Though I kinda wish he instead said “toyboat”, which used to be his other go-to improv bit when stumbling over a joke.
— Here comes an Eddie commentary as Raheem Abdul Muhammed. Weird seeing a (then) modern-day cast member at Chevy’s original season 1 Update set.
— Eddie’s overall commentary was okay, if nothing special. I liked the ending with him asking Chevy if he wants to buy some reefer. This also made me realize that this may have been the only time in SNL history we’ve seen Eddie and Chevy interacting with each other in person, unless I’m forgetting something.
— We finally get the debut of Laurie “She used to be on SNL?!?!” Metcalf, doing a pre-taped man-on-the-street segment where she asks pedestrians “Would you take a bullet for the president?” I take it this was right after the infamous President Reagan assassination attempt.
— Wait, we can’t even see Laurie Metcalf in this while pedestrians are answering her question.
— Oh, now we can see Laurie. Boy, does it feel weird seeing a young version of her on SNL.
— I recall hearing this is the only thing Laurie appears in tonight, meaning she made no live appearances for her first (and what would go on to be ONLY) episode. But hey, that’s still more than what her fellow featured player Emily Prager supposedly gets to do tonight, from what I’ve heard.
— Boy, these pedestrians’ answers to Laurie’s question are not funny at all. What’s the point of this whole segment?
— After Laurie’s segment ends, we just cut to a commercial break, with no cut back to Chevy at the Update desk. So, this is how tonight’s Update ends? Uh… okay.
STARS: **– oh, wait…


WEEKEND UPDATE, PART 2
ALF explains what happened to the show & wants to “Put SNL To Sleep”

     

— Oh, after the commercial break, we’re back with a continuation of Update. Wow, this may be the only time in SNL history where a Weekend Update had an actual commercial break in the middle of it. Weird. There are some old Comedy Central reruns that used to add a commercial break into the middle of somewhat lengthy Dennis Miller Updates (there were at least two instances of this: the Rob Lowe episode from season 15, and the Kyle MacLachlan episode from season 16), but I don’t count those because those were only added for syndication.
— We get a Don Pardo voice-over intro at the beginning of this half of Update, unlike the first half.
— A callback to the traditional Generalissimo Francisco Franco joke.
— Just now when a joke received tepid audience reaction, Chevy ad-libbed a “The writers strike continues” remark.
— Man, these jokes are just plain weak. Chevy keeps trying to save them by constantly making little ad-libs after every joke, but the problem is, the ad-libs ain’t funny either. That shows how much Chevy’s off his game tonight, because season 1 Chevy would’ve been more successful in his attempts to save bad jokes.
— Al Franken!!!
— A continuation of the gag with Franken’s name being displayed on the bottom of the screen every time he says “me – Al Franken”.
— The audience automatically applauds Al for simply saying he’s not part of the new SNL.
— This has turned into a very meta commentary, with Al doing a quick recap of SNL’s history and addressing the problems of this troubled season.
— Ha, loved Al’s harsh comment about how SNL got even better after Chevy left the cast.
— Al: “After four seasons, Danny and John left. Now THEM, we missed.”
— Classic line from Al about how Dick Ebersol “doesn’t know dick”.
— Al: “The show is going to be a little better. No English-speaking person can do a worse job than Jean [Doumanian].“
— Very funny conclusion to Al’s commentary, with him announcing a “Put SNL To Sleep” campaign to put the show out of its misery.
— They shoehorn in a mention that Al and Tom Davis will be hosting next week’s SNL with musical guest The Grateful Dead… which we, of course, never ended up getting to see.
— Overall, a fantastic commentary from Al, and I love how rebellious and frank it felt, reminding me of the ballsy anti-Fred Silverman commentary he did the previous season.
— Awkward ending to tonight’s Update with the camera still staying on Chevy long after he signed off, which he tries to ad-lib his way out of by drinking from a glass of water.
STARS: (FOR BOTH UPDATE HALVES ALTOGETHER) **½


SAME
“Same” is how Irene Cara (GLM) musically describes her performances

  

— I got a good laugh from Gail’s lyric about getting yeast infections from wearing those jeans all the time.
— A catchy parody of “Fame” so far, and a fun performance from Gail. I can already tell this song is going to be stuck in my head for a while.
— I liked the fourth wall-breaking extended ending, showing Gail and the back-up dancers dancing their way out of the studio. In hindsight, that has kind of a bittersweet feel to it, knowing what unfortunately lies ahead for Gail’s SNL future.
— Overall, while I’m sure I would’ve found this sketch even funnier if I had been around for the apparent over-saturation of “Fame” back in those days, I still found this to be a fun and enjoyable piece.
STARS: ***½


THE SELF-RIGHTEOUS
holier-than-thou characters populate a new NBC series

   

— Oh, so Robin Duke IS in a sketch tonight.
— This sketch beginning with Robin and Tony as the only performers onscreen makes me feel like I’m watching something from the later years of SCTV. Part of that feeling could also be due to the fact that the copy of the episode I’m watching (which is a recording of the original live broadcast) actually includes an SCTV rerun that aired right after this episode.
— So far, this is a pretty funny parody of the “overdramatic, self-important line deliveries” trope of hospital TV dramas.
— LOL at Eddie as a patient coming out of the operating room mid-surgery to join in on the doctors’ argument.
STARS: ***


WEDDING DAY
an Italian father (TOR) gives son Frank (TIK) advice on his wedding day

   

— Right out of the gate in his first episode, we get an over-the-top Italian-accented character from Tony Rosato. From what I’ve heard about the upcoming season 7, I’m in for quite a number of Italian stereotype characters from Tony throughout that season.
— Some good fast-paced delivery from Tony throughout this.
— Funny line from Tim about Tony strangling chickens in front of his fiancee.
— Liked the part with Tony slapping Tim for calling him a “wop”.
— A very realistic slice-of-life scene so far, but is there going to be an end to this lengthy sketch?
— A good laugh from the way Tony screamed “Mariaaaa!!!” when yelling out the door for more wine.
— Ha, during Tim and Tony’s various rapid-fire fighting gestures during their argument just now, Tim did a Curly-from-the-Three-Stooges gesture with his hand on top of his head.
— Very funny part with Tim and Tony showing the mother their crude crotch-thrusting gesture.
— Overall, this had its highlights, was a good showcase for the new guys, and I appreciate what this was going for, but MAN, what an overlong sketch. There were at least three times where I thought it would end, only for it to continue.
STARS: **½


THE FAMOUS BROADCASTERS SCHOOL OF CUE CARD READING
(JOP) is a product of the Famous Broadcasters School of Cue Card Reading

  

— Feels like the first time in a while we’ve seen Joe as a commercial pitchman. Charles Rocket seemed to slowly take that role away from him as this season progressed.
— Oh, he’s doing an ad for a school of cue card reading. I had been wondering why he kept diverting his eyes back-and-forth from the camera to the side of the camera.
— The part with his delays at keeping up with the back-and-forth camera switching is pretty funny.
— Good part with Tim.
STARS: ***


MUSICAL GUEST INTRO
CHC says SNL is OK but Christopher Reeve & Robin Williams [real] disagree

 

— Random Robin Williams and Christopher Reeve cameo.
— Decent bit with with Chevy saying SNL’s had its ups-and-downs and is currently “on its way back up” only for Williams and Reeve to refuse to back him up on that.
STARS: N/A (not a rateable segment)


MUSICAL PERFORMANCE
musical guest performs “How Sweet It Is”
musical guest performs “What Does It Take”


WILD COUNTRY GUN CARDS
Wild Country Gun Cards’ firearm facts promote family togetherness

   

— Feels weird seeing Denny being paired with some of the new cast members.
— An okay concept with the family jovially reading off graphic gun descriptions.
— Denny’s delivery of “It’s a ladies gun!” made me laugh.
— Strange bit role for Eddie at the end.
STARS: **½


BAG LADY
critics decry bag lady’s (DED) adherence to stereotypes of homeless genre

   

— I’ve always been kinda curious to see this. I think I remember hearing that this is a very strange, unconventional film with a negative reputation.
— What’s with the off-camera voices gossiping about Denny’s character? And what’s with that stuff they’re saying about Denny’s character just being an actress. I have no idea what they’re going for here.
— And that’s it? What the…?
— Overall, wow, I was pretty much lost during this. If they were trying to go for some kind of “deep” dramatic piece, I can’t help but feel they missed the mark. Maybe this whole film just went over my head.
STARS: *½


GOODNIGHTS
Irene Cara (GLM) reprises “Same”

     

— The usual season 6 home base stage looks so out-of-place in tonight’s episode; I guess because of how drastically different this episode feels from the prior episodes of this season.
— We get a continuation of Gail’s “Same” number as Chevy carries her in his arms.
— Gail ad-libs an out-of-character “You gotta put me down now, Chevy” right before the goodnights get cut off in the live version I’m watching. I want to see how the rest of these unique goodnights go, so I’m quickly gonna pull up the rerun version of this episode with the full goodnights.
— (Two minutes later…) Okay, here it is. Picking up where I left off in the live version, Gail continues to sing while dancing her way off the home base stage and going around the studio. Everyone else on stage follow her one-by-one in a line. Fun way to do the goodnights; kinda reminds me of the “conga line” goodnights in the Desi Arnaz episode from season 1.
— Strange seeing the scrolling ending credits being displayed in a different font from the one they typically used in the first 6 seasons. Tonight’s font would never be used for the goodnights again after this, as far as I know.


IMMEDIATE POST-SHOW THOUGHTS:
— Wow. Well, I went into this expecting a unique, strange-feeling episode, and that’s certainly what I got. This episode had a definite rebuilding/transitional vibe to it. At the same time, it had kind of an underlying sense of “What if this ends up being the final SNL episode ever?”, which is kinda sad and eerie when I think about it. Yet another interesting thing about this episode is that parts of it felt like I was watching a season premiere, which I guess is due to the fact that we had so many new cast members making their debut.
— This overall episode was okay. A little rough around the edges and was not anything I’d call great, nor was it the massive instant improvement over the Doumanian era that people may have been expecting. However, you can definitely see the promise and potential there.
— This would end up being the final episode of the season due to the aforementioned writers strike. This turned out to be a blessing in disguise for Dick Ebersol, as he now had much more time to do a more complete retooling of SNL than the measly five weeks he had been given between the preceding Bill Murray episode and tonight’s episode.
— This turned out to be the final episode for “veterans” (relatively speaking) Denny Dillon and Gail Matthius, as well as the two new featured players who got their “start” tonight: Laurie Metcalf and the unseen Emily Prager (which gives the former a strange, unique place in SNL history as the only cast member ever to only appear in pre-taped form for their entire tenure, while the latter is the only cast member ever to make ZERO appearances for their entire tenure). All four of these women would be casualties of Ebersol’s summer retooling of the show. I’m not too sad to see Denny go, though I didn’t have much of a problem with her throughout this season and she provided some laughs for me here and there. I just can’t help but view her as kinda expendable, though. Gail, on the other hand, did not deserve to get fired. She had some really positive qualities as a performer and seems like she would’ve fit really well into some of the better eras of the show. There were some rough moments with her, however: any potential she may have had as an Update anchor was ruined by her consistently being given some of the absolute worst Update jokes in SNL history, and I was a little put off by her suddenly starting to occasionally rely on overly-cartoonish antics during some of the sketches in the second half of the season. However, I blame the latter on the decreased confidence and increased sense of panic that most of the cast seemed to develop in the back half of the season. If Gail was kept on the show after this season and was given better writing than she got this year, who knows what greatness she could have achieved?
— So, what to say about the infamous Season 6 as a whole? When I started my reviews of this season, I predicted I would come out of the season feeling it was bad, but not quite as horrible as legend has it. That prediction turned out to be 100% correct. The first half of the season was undoubtedly rough, but had enough silver linings and occasional good episodes to keep me somewhat optimistic. However, during the second half of the season, immediately after the surprisingly strong Karen Black episode, this season hit the wall HARD. The great Karen Black episode was followed by a long consecutive string of dire and dreary episodes, where it felt like the show had suddenly given up and let all the bad press they were receiving get in their heads. Thankfully, they eventually got out of that slump, with Bill Murray injecting the cast and writers with tons of spirit and inspiration in the second-to-last episode and new producer Dick Ebersol transitioning the show to a promising new era in the last episode.


HOW THIS EPISODE STACKS UP AGAINST THE PRECEDING ONE (Bill Murray):
— a step down


My full set of screencaps for this episode is here


TOMORROW:

Season 7 begins. The show returns from writers strike and summer break with a more complete retooling, and we get introduced to MORE new faces in the cast. This will also be our second consecutive host-less episode.

36 Replies to “April 11, 1981 – (no host) / Jr. Walker & The All Stars (S6 E13)”

  1. In Hill and Weingrad’s book SATURDAY NIGHT, it is mentioned that Dick Ebersol wanted to fire Denny Dillon right away with the other three cast members but his budget didn’t allow it. That almost seems to say that he did consider keeping Gail Matthius. On one hand, I get that he maybe wanted to have as clean a slate as possible but I do agree that Gail had so much potential. While she had the least amount of confidence of her other female costars at times, she did have a quality that was worth letting grow more and more.

    The episode itself is very odd to say the least. It isn’t bad by any means but it is often hard for me to sit down and watch the episode. The “potential last show” vibe is oddly sad and eerie and it casts a strange aura over the proceedings. Plus, that Weekend Update segment with Chevy Chase weighs a lot down.

    And it sets us up for perhaps the oddest season in SNL’s history.

    1. If I remember right, Phil admitted it was pretty mean. His excuse was that nobody knows the real Frank, and he had to come up with something.

  2. Laurie Metcalf would appear on the show one more time, in a short film during Season 14 (during the Carvey/Hartman/Lovitz era, the show used a lot of outside submissions for short films, such as Ben Stiller’s “Color of Money” parody film.) It’s a shame she didn’t host this past season, when “Roseanne” was revived and she was up for an Oscar!

    The “Wild Country Gun Cards” sketch was originally written by O’Donoghue for Season 2 – it was rejected by the censors due to content back then.

  3. On Wikipedia, there’s a list of canceled episodes. I knew about Robert Guillaume/Ian Dury (before Jean was fired), Franken & Davis/Grateful Dead, and an episode with Dan Aykroyd. The others listed surprised me; anyone know if these are legit?
    Steve Martin/Neil Young, Brooke Shields/Tom Petty, and most surprising: Buck Henry/REO Speedwagon.
    The musical guest for Aykroyd is also listed as Pat Benatar (which I hadn’t heard before). This season had some very eclectic, out of left field musical guests, so the list of superstars intrigues me. But maybe Ebersol just didn’t want to take any chances.

    1. Dan Aykroyd, yes – I believe that one is real. Buck Henry refused to host after the original cast left, so that one is definitely fake.

    2. Oh wow. I had never seen that full list of shows that would have finished out Spring of 81. I was surprised Pat Benatar had never been a musical guest on the show given her popularity in the 80s. I would have loved to have seen how that Aykroyd episode and her would have played out.

  4. Ok, here are our five star sketches from the dreaded 80-81 season:

    Fish Heads (Ellen Burstyn)
    Script In Development (Bill Murray)

    Two. And a generous two at that. I think stooge mostly gets it right for this season. I love finding the hidden gems of the year, but nothing is really belongs to the upper echelon. The Livelys is a great success and there are a couple decent Rocket Reports, but yeah, nothing that really threatens five star status. The one thing I would say is that this season’s Nick the Lounge Singer sketch is as good as any that the show did. Murray really goes all out in that episode.

  5. As a companion piece to Carson’s list, here’s an Honorable Mentions list compiled of all the sketches I rated four-and-a-half stars this infamous season:

    Eddie Murphy kills time (Ray Sharkey)
    Livelys (Karen Black)
    Stroke Victim (Karen Black)
    Mister Robinson’s Neighborhood (Charlene Tilton)
    It Just Doesn’t Matter (Bill Murray)
    Monologue (Bill Murray)

  6. When Laurie Metcalf was on Marc Maron’s WTF podcast about a year ago, she recalled that she barely remembered this very brief SNL stint – apparently Ebersol was looking to try out one more potential female cast member, so Tim Kazurinsky recommended Laurie, as he knew her from Steppenwolf Theatre in Chicago. When she got there, they gave her the script for the Update pre-tape, had her shoot it, and that was that – the experience was just really a blur for her, so she wasn’t surprised they didn’t ask her back in the fall.

  7. A recent article in the New York Times about Laurie Metcalf said she was in one live sketch titled “Women From Mars” that got cut after dress.

  8. Here are the average ratings for Season 6:
    *may not represent review’s perception*

    601: 5.5 (Elliott Gould)
    602: 4.6 (Malcolm McDowell)
    603: 5.9 (Ellen Burstyn)
    604: 4.8 (Jamie Lee Curtis)
    605: 5.7 (David Carradine)
    606: 5.5 (Ray Sharkey)
    607: 6.6 (Karen Black)
    608: 4.3 (Robert Hays)
    609: 4.7 (Sally Kellerman)
    610: 4.2 (Deborah Harry)
    611: 4.6 (Charlene Tilton)
    612: 6.7 (Bill Murray)
    613: 5.6 (no host)

    Best Episode: 612 (Bill Murray)- 6.7
    Worst Episode: 610 (Deborah Harry)- 4.2
    Season Average: 5.3

    1. I’m curious what Vax Novier’s list of average ratings would look like if it was ranked from best episode to worst, so I’ll do it below:

      612: 6.7 (Bill Murray)
      607: 6.6 (Karen Black)
      603: 5.9 (Ellen Burstyn)
      605: 5.7 (David Carradine)
      613: 5.6 (no host)
      601: 5.5 (Elliott Gould)
      606: 5.5 (Ray Sharkey)
      604: 4.8 (Jamie Lee Curtis)
      609: 4.7 (Sally Kellerman)
      602: 4.6 (Malcolm McDowell)
      611: 4.6 (Charlene Tilton)
      608: 4.3 (Robert Hays)
      610: 4.2 (Deborah Harry)

      Biggest surprises:
      — Nothing, really, though I see from these rating averages that I was even tougher in my reviews of this season than I remembered.
      — A lot of people might be surprised that the infamous Malcolm McDowell episode isn’t ranked even lower, but look past all of the notoriously horrible sketches in that one and you’ll find a few good things.

  9. I didn’t get to watch this particular ep until the rerun of the week before the 7th season started. So I missed Drive for America (which was replaced by the first Mister Robinson’s Neighborhood) and Bag Lady (which was replaced by 60 Minutes with Joe Piscopo’s Dan Rather). I eventually saw the first one online during the year of the show’s 40th anniversary but I’ve yet to see the second one. Maybe the Peacock site will eventually air an uncensored version a few months from now…

  10. I finally got to see the original recording yesterday. Getting to see the material as intended, without pieces of other episodes dumped in, helped make for a better viewing experience, even if I still found the episode more interesting for historical purposes than for entertainment.

    Ebersol basically broke up the show into:

    – nostalgia (Chevy, Al)
    – showcases for the inherited cast he had interest in (or potential interest), with Eddie getting an extra leg up with both a solo sketch and an Update appearance
    – showcasing the new cast he actually had interest in (Robin and the other ladies already out of luck…)

    It’s not a bad idea on paper, but onscreen it doesn’t quite click. I would have left Chevy to the cold open, and if he needed to be on Update, leave him to a shorter role, or even co-anchoring with someone like Tim (or Emily Prager as she wasn’t anywhere in the episode). The Update drags this down a fair amount. Even Al, who is in his usual good form, wears on me, because a piece so devoted to dogging the show in his absence wilts a bit when the episode he has his comeback in isn’t exactly firing on all cylinders.

    My favorite bit was the Self-Righteous sketch – a biting parody of phony TV dramas of the time, and one that still holds up for TV today (and also sadly true to life, not just TV). It’s a contrast to the Fame parody, which I really wanted to enjoy (a showcase for Gail, fun singing and dancing, and even including writer/future cast member Terry Sweeney), but is bogged down by being overlong, having too many lyrics, and too much shrillness from Gail.

    I really like these low-budget credits – for me seeing the cast trying to pose in “normal” situations works more than the generic B&W head shots of 82-84. The bumpers are especially one of a kind – seeing Joe Piscopo hunched in a bathroom stall is something you wouldn’t expect.

    I felt like Tony was trying to be more Belushi-esque in this episode than he would in the next season (especially in the gun sketch – boy is it weird watching that in June 2020). The long piece with Tim wasn’t for me but I did appreciate their efforts (and also wondered why they didn’t try to make Tony look old enough to be Tim’s father).

    The Sinatra sketch is, while well-performed by Joe and Tim, a tough watch, thanks to the padding and also to the confused tone (are we meant to be put off by their racism or laugh along with it?). Having this as the kickoff The commercials on the tape including several segments involving Japanese people just make the whole thing feel even more dated even in its own time. The irony is that Piscopo’s Sinatra being “nicer” than Phil Hartman’s version is that it makes this material feel dishonest and ends up making his version more unpleasant as a result.

    The Denny bag lady film is what I really wanted to see in this version, because I wanted to see her farewell piece and because the reviews are so negative. I didn’t hear until recently that they had redone the piece because the original was deemed as too bad to air. The few glimpses we get here don’t seem that bad to me, and I wish we could see the full original film to be able to judge. What we do see, with the MST3K forerunner of commentary, mostly leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Denny was such a spark plug through season 6, giving energy and personality yet never trying to derail material by making it all about her. Even if Ebersol never planned to bring her back, reducing her to bit parts and only showing her in a larger role in a piece where she is jeered and negatively compared to Carol Burnett just feels like a needlessly sour ending, not to mention a forerunner for the fate of most women in this era sans, I suppose, Mary Gross.

    1. I meant to say I thought having the Sinatra piece as the kickoff post-credits wasn’t a great idea and sort of set a bad tone for the night.

    2. Hi. I’m wondering where you were able to see the original recording recently. I’ve been as big an SNL fan as anyone I know since the mid-90s and yet these “original airings with commercials” that some fans have access to are one thing I’ve never been able to locate. Any info you could give me would be, well, frankly amazing.

  11. The ironic thing about Robin and Tony being on ‘SNL’ is that they were on ‘SCTV’ the year before when that show made fun of ‘SNL’ and ‘Fridays’ with the Thursday Night Live sketch. That was a great send-up of both shows.

  12. I was in college when this aired; the tasteless Cosby beer commercial has stuck with e all these years. laugh-out-loud funny then and now, even with what we know now! Hey, thanks for reviewing these!

    1. The man with the cowboy hat was the chimpanzee trainer for I Married a Monkey. He was always seen with the cast during goodnights on shows that featured the sketch.

  13. We watched this episode in abbreviated form on the Peacock app. I’m glad to be able to see at least SOME of each episode from the older SNL years (even season 6), but it’s kinda disappointing to find out what parts were removed and what parts were left in.
    I would’ve liked to see the “Same” sketch, but that’s gone; they even removed the Goodnights segment altogether and replaced it with generic slides of NYC.
    But we have to be thankful for what we can get.

  14. After editing the episode to my preference for future viewing I saved:

    LITE BEER
    In a bar, Bill Cosby (EDM) tries to sell a group of kids on Lite Beer

    WEEKEND UPDATE, PART 1
    Smitt-Burney makes money the old-fashioned way, they steal it
    Raheem Abdul Muhammed saw Altered States but thought it was Stir Crazy
    LAM asks pedestrians “Would you take a bullet for our president?”

    WEEKEND UPDATE, PART 2
    ALF explains what happened to the show & wants to “Put SNL To Sleep”

    The video I was able to obtain for this episode is the “Eddie Murphy Experience” version. It has the 60 Minutes and Mr. Robinson’s Neighborhood segments from previous episodes included but is missing:

    DRIVE FOR AMERICA
    Jingoistic Frank Sinatra (JOP) bashes Japan & promotes American cars

    BAG LADY
    Critics decry bag lady’s (DED) adherence to stereotypes of homeless genre

  15. Estimated uncut length of Season 6: 13.5 hours
    Lugatz’s cut length of Season 6: 3 hours, 49 minutes, 55 seconds
    Estimated subjective percentage of quality material: 28%

    Final subjective rankings based on length of quality material from best to worst:

    E12 – Bill Murray, Delbert McClinton – 49:48
    E07 – Karen Black, Cheap Trick, Stanley Clarke Trio – 24:12
    E09 – Sally Kellerman, Jimmy Cliff – 21:54
    E13 – No Host, Jr. Walker & The All Stars – 19:23
    E11 – Charlene Tilton, Todd Rundgren, Prince – 18:40
    E06 – Ray Sharkey, Jack Bruce & Friends – 16:09
    E04 – Jamie Lee Curtis, James Brown, Ellen Shipley – 15:44
    E03 – Ellen Burstyn, Aretha Franklyn, Keith Sykes – 13:14
    E08 – Robert Hays, Joe ‘King’ Carrasco & The Crowns, 14 Karat Soul – 12:25
    E01 – Elliot Gould, Kid Creole & The Coconuts – 11:08
    E05 – David Carradine, Linda Ronstadt, The Cast Of The Pirates Of Penzance – 10:25
    E02 – Malcolm McDowell, Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band – 9:11
    E10 – Deborah Harry, Funky Four Plus One – 7:36

  16. Having finally completed my viewing of SNL Season 6, I have to say that I enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would. I watched the first five seasons in order just before it, so I think I have a pretty good frame of reference for what the public experienced with this transition to the new cast. In some ways, it was actually more interesting than Season 5, because there was more of a sense of the unknown. How would this new group handle the task of replacing the beloved originals?

    I was surprised that despite the cast and writing staff turnover, it still felt like the old show in many ways. The atmosphere retained that gritty underground theater vibe that the original era was known for. I would say that this one-off season finale actually felt like more of a jarring difference than the beginning of the season did.

    After all the legends about how this was SNL’s worst season ever, I was expecting it to be a trainwreck, but I found that despite its obvious problems, it had a few excellent episodes, and several others that were at least watchable. And I actually grew attached to the cast, strangely enough. I found it sad to see most of them go.

    Keeping Eddie and Joe was a no-brainer, as they were the most consistent crowd-pleasers throughout the season. It was fun to watch 19-year-old Eddie Murphy go from featured player to breakout star over the course of a few episodes. Though he’s significantly younger than the rest of the cast, he already seems more polished than most of them. His charisma and comic sensibility are obvious from the get-go. And as for Joe, he sort of took over the Dan Aykroyd glue player role, even sounding like Dan when he did his sportcaster character. Guys like that are invaluable to any ensemble.

    I’m not surprised that Denny and Gail both survived the initial purge, as they were the most reliable performers among the women. They were both likable, funny, and did great character work, and I wish they’d been given another season. Watching them now, they seem like hidden gems.

    It was fascinating to see young Gilbert Gottfried in action. He almost seemed like a prototype version of the shrill madman who went on to a long comedy career. The persona is there, but it’s not yet fully formed. He may have simply been a bad fit for SNL’s format, as it seems like he was more of a standup at heart. He wasn’t really suited to play everyman roles in sketches.

    Ann Risley was all right, but her firing wasn’t a great loss. She was a very unremarkable performer. She seemed perfectly competent in generic straight roles, but she rarely did anything that stood out, and she often seemed to struggle when she had to do real character work.

    And Charles Rocket, what can you say about him? He kind of became the poster boy for everything that went wrong this season. It’s hard to know what to make of him, since there seem to be various narratives about him. Some say he was an arrogant egomaniac who caused trouble behind the scenes, others say he was a nice guy who just acted pompous in front of the camera. Whatever the truth is, he was given the enormous task of becoming the new face of the show, and he had the odds stacked against him.

    His Rocket Reports had their moments, because he apparently used to make satirical news reports like that during his pre-SNL days, so he was a natural at it. Weekend Update, on the other hand, was a complete disaster. I think most of the blame for that should go to the awful writing, but he didn’t do himself any favors by hamming it up trying to wring laughter out of weak material. Still, I feel bad for him, because bombing on live television has to be tough. Since he didn’t come from a standup comedy background, he probably wasn’t prepared for how to handle bombing, and he didn’t have the natural poise of a Chevy Chase, who could play off a bad audience reaction by ad-libbing something funny.

    As for the F-bomb, Rocket apparently maintained throughout his life that it just slipped out, but others who were there said he said it on purpose. Whatever the case, it seemed like he came to regret it. It’s a shame that it ended up overshadowing some of the good work he did on the show, like the aforementioned Rocket Reports and sketches like the Livelys. Even though he’s somewhat been cast as a heel in SNL’s history, I find it hard to dislike the guy, especially knowing that he had inner demons that eventually led him to take his own life.

    At the end of the day, I feel like this cast was a great “what if?” What if they’d had better writing and a better producer? What if the show hadn’t shot itself in the foot by inviting comparisons to the original cast early on? What if they’d handled media criticism better? What if they’d been given more time to develop? We can only wonder.

    Having watched all three of the famous “troubled” seasons in their entirety (S6, S11, S20), I think I liked this one best. Season 11 was a case of a cast with no chemistry drifting through tepid material week after week. It was more bland than awful. Season 20 was a case of established performers half-assing their way through lazily-written sketches week after week and often insulting the audience’s intelligence in the process. With Season 6, it felt like they were at least trying their hardest, but the writing needed more maturity, and the show as a whole needed to do a better job of getting the audience on their side.

    I guess it’s on to the Ebersol era for me. I’m sure the quality of the show will improve, but I wonder if it’ll be as interesting a phenomenon to observe as this season was.

    1. My theory of Rocket is that he never elevated or denigrated the material he got: when he performs you get a good bead on the quality of what was written. For all his desperation on WU (especially toward the end) he was always professional and never giggled or broke in front of the camera. I think it would have been better if they’d made him a featured player and let him
      focus on the Rocket Reports (which better suited his art school background) with some featured sketch player roles to build his chops.

      Dillon and Matthius were great, and I’m sorry they didn’t get another chance. But I fear Matthius might have become Robin Duke in future seasons: talented and criminally underused.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from The 'One SNL a Day' Project

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading